| (*) Musical Production ~ (+) Non Season Production | |
| 1990 | Luv + |
| Bleacher Bums + | |
| Messiah*+ | |
| Steel Magnolias | |
| Annie Get Your Gun* | |
| Gaslight | |
| Grease* | |
| The Trial of the Big Bad Wolf* | |
| 1991 | Love Letters + |
| How to Eat Like a Child | |
| Bell, Book and Candle | |
| Annie* | |
| Aesop's Fallables | |
| The Trip to Bountiful | |
| 1992 | How to Eat Like a Child + |
| The Sound of Music* | |
| Joseph and the Amazing Tricolor Dreamcoat* | |
| The Odd Couple | |
| 1993 | The Music Man |
| Rumors | |
| Ducktails and Bobbysox | |
| Quilters | |
| 1994 | High Noon in Gloom Town + |
| Damn Yankees | |
| Bye, Bye Birdie | |
| Dorothy Meets Alice* | |
| Dracula | |
| 1940's Radio Hour + | |
| 1995 | Little Shop of Horrors* |
| The Secret Garden* | |
| 3 1/2 Musketeers* | |
| 1996 | Murder at Rutherford House + |
| Nunsense* | |
| Crazy For You* | |
| Charlotte's Web | |
| The Sunshine Boys | |
| Forever Plaid* | |
| 1997 | My Fair Lady* |
| The Octette Bridge Club | |
| Hansel and Gretel* | |
| Pump Boys and Dinettes* | |
| 1998 | Broadway Babylon + |
| Fiddler on the Roof* | |
| Fools | |
| You're a Good Man Charlie Brown* | |
| My Emperor's New Clothes* | |
| 1999 | Nunsense II* |
| Arsenic & Old Lace | |
| Cinderella* | |
| Annie Jr.* | |
| 2000 | Cemetery Club |
| Meet Me in St. Louis* | |
| Death of a Salesman | |
| Kilroy Was Here* | |
| 2001 | The Wizard of Oz* |
| Bachelor and the Sobbysoxer | |
| Barefoot in the Park | |
| 2002 | You Can't Take it With You |
| A Midsummer's Night Dream | |
| Krazy Kamp* | |
| Honky Tonk Angels* | |
| 2003 | Always Patsy Cline* |
| Godspell* | |
| Over the River and Through the Woods | |
| Lucky Dollar Private Eye | |
| Into the Woods* | |
| 2004 | Love Rides the Rails |
| Once Upon a Time and Far Away: A Tale of Cinderella | |
| Here Lies Jeremy Troy | |
| Two By Two* | |
| 2005 | |
| I Do! I Do! | |
| The Best Christmas Pagent Ever | |
| 2006 | See How They Run |
| The Patchwork Girl of Oz | |
| South Pacific | |
| Tribute | |
